May 3, 2018
Module 15: Censorship Issues
Module 15: Censorship Issues
Title:
Genre: Young Adult/Verse Novel
Book Summary:
Sophomore year, the year of friends and boys boys boys. Sophie and her two best friends, Grace and Rachel, are boy crazy. Boys come and go throughout the year. Until her impromptu "stay-cation" during winter break when her two BFFs have left her to fend for herself. She heads to her favorite museum and, is surprised to find school reject, Murphy, (of the "you are such a Murphy!" fame), next to her favorite painting. From that first meeting, Sophie learns that true love comes in all different shapes and sizes. After spending her Christmas break with Murphy, also known as Robin, she realizes that she has to brace herself for her friends' reactions to her dating Robin/Murphy. She has a bit of a freakout and realizes that, despite the stares of her classmates, she wants to stay with him.
APA Reference of Book:
Sones, S. (2001). What My Mother Doesn’t Know. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster.
Impression:
I loved this book and the ease of reading free-verse. I have to say I am stunned that this book is on the banned books list for being "sexually explicit". The only things that happen in this book is kissing! This book is a perfect rendition of true teen angst. What 15-year-old girl hasn't liked boy after boy after boy! The way the book was written truly expresses the mind of a young girl. The scene where she enters the cafeteria and is torn between sitting with Rachel and Grace or, incurring the wrath of negative stares by all students and sitting with Robin. "Is everyone/in the entire cafeteria/looking at me?/Or is it just my imagination?/I want to scream/I want to run away./I want to---" (Somes, 2001) Everyone who has EVER sat in a high school cafeteria, at one time or another, has been in the same situation as Sophie. I look forward to reading the next book, What MyGirlfriend Doesn't Know, written from the perspective of Robin/Murphy.
Professional Review:
Gr 6-8 --Astory written in poetry form. Sophie is happily dating Dylan, "until he's practically glued himself to my side." Then she falls for cyberboy ("if I could marry a font/I'd marry his"). Imagine her surprise when he becomes down-right scary. In the satisfying ending, Sophie finds the perfect boyfriend-someone she's known all along. Sones is a bright, perceptive writer who digs deeply into her protagonist's soul. There she reveals the telltale signs of being "boy crazy"; the exciting edginess of cyber romances; the familiar, timeless straggle between teens and parents; and the anguish young people feel when their parents fight. But life goes on, and relationships subtly change. Sones's poems are glimpses through a peep-hole many teens may be peering through for the first time, unaware that others are seeing virtually the same new, scary, unfamiliar things (parents having nuclear meltdowns, meeting a boyfriend's parents, crying for no apparent reason). In What My Mother Doesn't Know, a lot is revealed about the teenage experience-("could I really be falling for that geck I dissed a month ago?"), clashes with close friends, and self-doubts. It could, after all, be readers' lives, their English classes, their hands in a first love's. Of course, mothers probably do know these goings-on in their daughters' lives. It's just much easier to believe they don't. Sones's book makes these often-difficult years a little more livable by making them real, normal, and OK.
Korbeck, S. (2001). What My Mother Doesn't Know (Book Review). School Library Journal, 47(10), 171.
Korbeck, S. (2001). What My Mother Doesn't Know (Book Review). School Library Journal, 47(10), 171.
Library Use:
This book, such as others, could be used during Banned Books Week. ELA teachers could assign a banned book and have students reflect/react to the book being deemed a "banned book".
This book, such as others, could be used during Banned Books Week. ELA teachers could assign a banned book and have students reflect/react to the book being deemed a "banned book".
Read alikes:
The following are books that are written in verse format and are included on the banned book list. These could be read, in conjunction with Banned Books Week.
TTYL by Laura Miracle
Crank by Ellen Hopkins
A Bad Boy Can Be Good For a Girl by Tanya Lee Stone
TTYL by Laura Miracle
Crank by Ellen Hopkins
A Bad Boy Can Be Good For a Girl by Tanya Lee Stone